Machine strategy

Elvira's House of Horrors pinball tournament strategy: finish one haunt, then collect Trailer Trash

Elvira's House of Horrors hides its tournament points in a hurry-up most players never collect. How haunts start and score, why Trailer Trash is the payoff, which multiballs are worth the locks, and what 377 tracked games say about who wins on it.

·7 min read·Tilt Stats

Elvira's House of Horrors is Stern's 2019 return to the Elvira license, with a full-size mansion in the middle of the playfield. It has 377 tracked tournament games in our data, split almost evenly between Bad Penny Pinball Arcade and Broken Clock Brewing Cooperative in Minneapolis, with a run at LITT Pinball Bar and a handful at Blainbrook.

The rules are deep: ten B-movie modes, three garage multiballs, a trunk and a crypt. A tournament game sees a small slice of that. What matters in three balls is one finished haunt and the hurry-up it lights.

The short version

  1. Plunge for the Back Door skill shot. It pays a million and qualifies a haunt at the house.
  2. Shoot the house until it flashes purple, then shoot it again to start a haunt. Pick one with a short first stage.
  3. Finish the haunt. Each shot raises both the base value and the final shot, and the final shot starts at two million.
  4. Shoot the house again for Trailer Trash, a hurry-up worth half the haunt's points. Hit both ramps first and it pays all of them.
  5. Use the garage drop target between haunts. Three locks start a multiball you can run under the next mode.
  6. Drain or time out in a haunt and that haunt is gone for the game. Do not start one with a ball you cannot control.

Skill shots

Skill shotAward
Dead End lanes250,000, up 25,000 per skill shot made, and the bonus multiplier goes up 5x
Back Door1,000,000, up 250,000 per Back Door made, capped at 2,500,000

The Back Door is the one to practice. On top of the points, it qualifies a haunt at the house entrance, or starts one outright if a haunt is already qualified. During a haunt or Gappa Angry it spots the next mode shot instead.

Haunts

The house entrance starts the modes. Shoot it enough times for the light to flash purple, then one more shot starts the haunt. The flippers pick which window, and so which movie, you play. Six are open from the start; four more need a Skeleton Key from the trunk.

The scoring frame is the same for every haunt. The base value starts at 500,000 and the final shot at 2,000,000. Each shot you make collects the base value and raises both numbers. The clock starts at 45 seconds, pauses while the ball is in the pop bumpers, and a lit shot made with under 15 seconds left resets it to 15.

HauntWindowFirst stage
Night of the Living DeadRight basementShots at a 500,000 increment, then destroy four ghouls to light the cellar
Teenagers from Outer SpaceLeft atticThree shots at 250,000 plus 50,000 each, then the right spinner at 1% of the final shot per spin
The Brain That Wouldn't DieLeft garageFlashing white shot at 500,000, then the house, then four shots to light the cellar
The MansterRight garageFive shots to qualify the house, then turn off all six shots
Manos: The Hands of FateRight middle floor250,000 shots, then a red shot, then three shots to light the cellar
The Werewolf of WashingtonRight atticEither orbit to Transform for 500,000 plus 50,000 each, then a seven-second combo chain

Teenagers from Outer Space has the shortest first stage, three shots plus one for every haunt you have already completed, and on paper it is the quickest one to finish. Werewolf of Washington is the high-ceiling choice: its combo stage pays the base value plus 125,000 times (N squared minus N), where N is the combo count, with seven seconds between shots.

The penalty for failure is the part to keep in mind. If you drain or time out during a haunt, that haunt is locked until you reach They Came From Space, the six-haunt wizard mode, which in a tournament game means it is locked for good. Pick a haunt you can finish, and start it off a controlled ball.

Trailer Trash

This is where a tournament game on Elvira makes most of its points. After a finished haunt, the house entrance lights on a hurry-up for 50% of the total points you scored in that haunt. Shoot either ramp before collecting and it rises to 75%. Shoot both ramps and it pays 100%.

So a haunt is worth up to double what the mode display shows, as long as you collect. Trailer Trash can run during multiball, which means a garage multiball started right after a haunt gives you more balls to make the ramps and the house shot with.

Multiballs

Garage. The gravestone drop target in front of the garage lights locks: one hit for the first multiball, one hit per lock for the second, two per lock for the third. Three locked balls start each one.

MultiballJackpots
Wild WomenAll major shots except the garage at 350,000 plus 25,000 each; five jackpots light a 1,000,000 super at the house, then both orbits at 800,000 plus 25,000
Add-a-ZombieLeft orbit, house, crypt and right orbit at 500,000 plus 25,000 each; the garage adds a jackpot at a random shot
Attic AttackAll shots at 500,000 plus 25,000 each; every five jackpots light a super at the house worth the jackpot total

Trunk. The trunk targets pick a junk item (Skeleton Key, Lab Test, Elvira's Dagger or the Atomic Raygun), completing them lights the trunk, and the left ramp collects the item and locks a ball. Two locks start Trunk Multiball, a two-ball with two roaming jackpots and a super at the left ramp.

Where the ball drains

The left outlane has a safety net you can earn. Completing the right target bank lights Hand of Fate there, and a left-outlane drain with it lit spins a wheel you stop with the action button within six seconds. Ball Save is one of the awards, along with 5,000,000, 2,000,000, Double Bone-Us and Extend Multiball. It is a gamble, and it is the only thing between you and the drain on that side.

The rulesheet we used says nothing about nudging or dangerous feeds, so from the data we will say only this. Play order is flat here: in 119 full four-player games the average finish by seat runs from 2.46 to 2.55, about as even as it gets. The general question is in does play order matter.

What the tracked games say

Tracked tournament games377
Tournaments it appeared in176
Players with a game on it232
Typical game20:35
Upset rate32.1%
Difficulty28 out of 100

Numbers are as of early November 2026. The Elvira's House of Horrors machine page has the live ones.

The upset rate is how often the lower-rated player in a pairing finishes ahead. At 32.1%, Elvira is under the series average of 35.7%. Like Godzilla and the other long, deep Sterns, it favors the stronger player, and it is a sound pick if you are the favorite in your group. The full table is in upset rates by machine. A typical game runs 20 minutes, among the longer ones in this series, which matters in a round with a time limit.

No one has run away with it. Among players with at least 20 tracked games on it, Jack Copeland has the best record, 11 firsts in 24 games (five of them outright, the rest shared in qualifying ties), finishing ahead of 61% of his opponents. Andy Fleming has six outright wins in 23 games, Louis Acre-Kendall three in 23, and Mike Jacobson five in 20. Rob Koppelman has played it more than anyone on the board, 28 games. And yes, a player named Elvira Khanaveral has 24 tracked games on it, with six outright wins. The scouting report will tell you how your own group has done.

Where to play it

Stern's game page lists Premium, Limited, Signature and Blood Red Kiss editions and no Pro, so the mansion, the crypt and the trunk are on every one you will meet.

Before your next game

The Elvira's House of Horrors playbook has player tips, videos and rulesheet links, and the scores tab includes Insider Connected scores from local venues. The rules in this guide come from the Pinball Rulesheets wiki, which documents code 1.01, with the toy descriptions from Stern's game page.

For other Sterns of the same era, see Stranger Things, Jurassic Park and The Munsters, which came out the same year. The whole series is in the machine strategy guides.