Fred's Birthday at NPC: 43 players, 162 head-to-head games, and the birthday boy made the final eight
A Friday night four-strike at Northstar Pinball Collective ran 162 head-to-head games on 52 machines in under eleven minutes each. Luke Nahorniak and Dave Prosen tied at the top of the knockout, Nahorniak won the final four, and Fred Gams, whose birthday it was, finished tied third in qualifying.
·5 min read·Tilt Stats
Friday night at Northstar Pinball Collective is a standing appointment, and on September 25, 2026 the appointment had a name on it. Luke Nahorniak ran a four-strike head-to-head knockout called Fred's Birthday, forty-three people came, and the man in the title finished tied for third in the knockout before the final eight sorted things out.
The numbers
| Players | 43 (26 with an IFPA rating) |
| Format | Head-to-head knockout, four strikes, then an eight-player final |
| Prize pool | $215 |
| TGP | 92% (IFPA grade) |
| WPPR to the winner | 14.4 |
| Knockout games | 162 across 52 machines |
| Finals games | 10 |
| Clocked playfield time | 27.8 hours in the knockout, averaging 10m17s a game |
Forty-three players is the ninth-largest field among the 364 completed tournaments on NPC's venue page as of early November 2026. The venue guide covers the room, 55 machines in Savage with a heavy tilt toward electromechanicals and early solid state. Fifty-two of them saw play here, which is nearly all of them in a single evening.
The organizer's description laid out the back half: finals when four players remain, three games in PAPA style, the high seed picking one modern, one mid-era and one classic game and choosing order on the first. The finals log shows eight players in two groups of four before a final four, so the bracket grew a little from the plan.
The IFPA graded it at 92%, which paid 14.4 WPPR to first, 8.9 to second and 6.4 to third. Head-to-head games count for less than four-player groups in the WPPR formula, which is why 162 games add up to a grade under 100%.
Ten minutes a game
The average game took 10 minutes and 17 seconds. That is what two players on a classic produce, and NPC has a lot of classics. Meteor averaged 6m02s across three games, Iron Maiden 6m55s across four, Black Jack and Cheetah 7m05s. The quickest game of the night was 4m47s on Avengers: Infinity Quest in round three, and the result is in the upsets section.
| Machine | Games | Average |
|---|---|---|
| Jurassic Park (Stern, 2019) | 5 | 11m29s |
| The Walking Dead (Stern, 2014) | 5 | 9m44s |
| Mustang (LE) (Stern, 2014) | 5 | 12m45s |
| Family Guy (Stern, 2007) | 5 | 11m59s |
| Black Knight: Sword of Rage (Stern, 2019) | 5 | 8m55s |
| Star Trek (Stern, 2018) | 5 | 13m51s |
| Genesis (Gottlieb, 1986) | 5 | 8m36s |
| Guardians of the Galaxy (Stern, 2017) | 4 | 16m54s |
The longest knockout game was 28m39s on Guardians of the Galaxy in round eleven, and it was the game that decided the top of the standings: Dave Prosen over Luke Nahorniak. Match Play clocks the gap between assignment and result entry, so a long stamp can include waiting, but twenty-nine minutes for two good players on Guardians is believable. Nothing else in the knockout cracked twenty minutes.
How the knockout went
Eleven rounds of head-to-head play. Lose four and you are out.
| Pos | Player | Strikes | Games | Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Luke Nahorniak | 2 | 10 | 8 |
| 1 | Dave Prosen | 2 | 10 | 8 |
| 3 | Andy Fleming | 3 | 11 | 8 |
| 3 | Fred Gams | 3 | 10 | 7 |
| 3 | Luke Mutchler | 3 | 10 | 7 |
| 3 | David Chapman | 3 | 10 | 7 |
| 7 | Daniel Mickelson | 4 | 11 | 7 |
| 7 | Brooke Hipsher | 4 | 11 | 7 |
| 7 | Jessica Anderson | 4 | 11 | 7 |
| 10 | John Snyder | 4 | 9 | 5 |
| 10 | Thomas Como | 4 | 10 | 6 |
Nahorniak, ranked 15 in the world as of the event date, and Prosen, ranked 4,645, both finished on two strikes from ten games. Fred Gams, ranked 7,737, won seven of ten and shared third with Andy Fleming, Luke Mutchler and David Chapman. Three players had their first tracked tournament here: Gabriel Montante and Kate Nelson both won three games and tied for 23rd, and Tony Jorgensen won two.
The finals
The final eight split into two groups of four for three games each. Nahorniak, Fleming, Gams and Daniel Mickelson played King Kong, Mystery Castle and Paragon. Mickelson won Mystery Castle ahead of Nahorniak, Nahorniak won the other two, and Gams, on a 1979 Bally in a four-player game that ran 59 minutes and 46 seconds, finished ahead of Mickelson on Paragon. That was the longest game of the night.
The other group, Mutchler, Prosen, Chapman and Jessica Anderson, played Rush, Black Jack and Genesis. Mutchler won two, Prosen won Genesis, and Prosen and Chapman then played a 5m38s tiebreaker on Guardians of the Galaxy that Prosen won to take the last spot in the final four.
| Pos | Player | Final-four results |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Luke Nahorniak | 1st on Rush, 1st on Demolition Man, 3rd on Star Gazer |
| 2 | Dave Prosen | 3rd, 3rd, 1st on Star Gazer |
| 3 | Daniel Mickelson | 2nd, 2nd, 4th |
| 4 | Luke Mutchler | 4th, 4th, 2nd |
| 5 | David Chapman | |
| 6 | Andy Fleming | |
| 7 | Jessica Anderson | |
| 8 | Fred Gams |
Nahorniak won Rush and Demolition Man, Prosen won Star Gazer, and that order held. Mickelson, who had qualified seventh with four strikes, finished third. Mutchler finished fourth.
The upsets
Rank gaps use IFPA standing as of the event date.
The quickest game of the night was also the second-biggest upset. Kysa Nahorniak, ranked 20,596, beat Daniel Mickelson, ranked 2,605, on Avengers: Infinity Quest in round three, in 4 minutes and 47 seconds. A round earlier she had beaten Dave Prosen on Mars Trek. Mickelson went on to finish third; Prosen went on to finish second. Mickelson's profile covers his spring.
The biggest gap came in round one, Jenn Stromberg, ranked 24,976, over Tom Colburn, ranked 5,363, on Star Trek.
Nate Robertson, ranked 9,216, beat the number 15 player in the world on Granada in round four. He also beat Brian Spencer (2,400) on Bounty Hunter and Jeff Stenzel (2,955) on The Munsters. He and Nahorniak met twice on the night and split, and all time it is 31 games, 25-6 Nahorniak.
Fred Gams added one of his own in round nine, beating John Schollmeyer, ranked 1,860, on Mystery Castle.
Pairs with history
Head-to-head knockouts do not repeat pairings much; the two meetings between Nahorniak and Robertson were the most anyone was drawn together in the knockout. The finals are where the history lives.
- Dave Prosen vs Luke Mutchler have played 160 tracked games against each other, 85-73 to Mutchler. Six of them were here, in the same finals group and then the same final four, and Prosen took four.
- Luke Nahorniak vs Andy Fleming is 136 games, 101-19-16 to Nahorniak. Three more here, all to Nahorniak. Fleming has entered more tournaments than anyone in the state, and a lot of them had Nahorniak in them.
- Luke Nahorniak vs Daniel Mickelson is 69 games, 52-15-2 Nahorniak. Six here, 5-1.
- Luke Nahorniak vs Fred Gams is 20 games, 14-2-4 Nahorniak, including three here.
One raw score made it into the system: Paul Tvedt entered 46,340 on Pro-Football, a 1973 Gottlieb.
The point of a Friday like this
A four-strike head-to-head knockout with 43 players is 162 games in an evening, which is more pinball per hour than almost any other format, and NPC is one of the few rooms with enough machines to run it without a line. Fifty-two games saw play. The best player in the state won, the second-highest finisher was ranked outside the top 4,000, and the man whose birthday it was outlasted thirty-five people. The tournament page has every game.