Elton John pinball tournament strategy: pick your song, then stack the Croc and the Rocket
Steve Ritchie's first Jersey Jack game asks you to make a choice before the first plunge. Which song to pick, which skill shot to take, how to stack Crocodile Rock with Rocket Man, the Signature Stage trap, and what 292 tracked games say.
·6 min read·Tilt Stats
Elton John is Steve Ritchie's first game for Jersey Jack Pinball, released in November 2023. It reached Minnesota tournaments in January 2024 and has 292 tracked games since, most of them at LITT Pinball Bar and Blainbrook. It has results from 209 different players.
It is a deep game with songs, albums, ten milestones and two wizard modes, and a three-ball tournament game touches a small slice of it. Most games come down to a good song, a useful skill shot and a stacked multiball.
The short version
- At the start of the game, pick Tiny Dancer. It is the only song you get to choose.
- Time the plunge for a skill shot. Adv. Croc MB or Bonus X are the useful ones.
- Shoot the Rocka-Box drop targets for albums. The fourth album adds 15 seconds of ball save.
- Light Crocodile Rock locks at the Tiny Dancer target and lock two balls at the crocodile.
- Start Rocket Man while Crocodile Rock is running. Both sets of jackpots double.
- Earn the Honky Cat kickback early. The left outlane will thank you.
Skill shots
Five inserts above the plunger sweep up and down, and the lit one is awarded as the ball passes the opto above them.
| Insert | Award |
|---|---|
| Big Points | 200,000 |
| Bonus X | +1x bonus multiplier |
| Spot Star | One ELTON JOHN star, or a Signature Stage lock if lit |
| Rocket Fuel | 50 units of fuel |
| Adv. Croc MB | Lights a Crocodile Rock lock, or collects one if lit |
A short plunge feeds the upper flipper, and shooting the backstage loop or the side ramp from there collects a super skill shot with an extra perk. The Croc version adds 30,000 to the Crocodile Rock jackpot base, which one PinTips tip singles out. A full plunge resets and lights the drop targets instead: knock any one down for about 50,000 and the next album. A mid-strength plunge into the jets cancels both, so commit to soft or full.
Each skill shot you collect makes the inserts sweep faster, so take the good ones early.
Songs and wardrobe
You choose one of 15 songs at the start. After that each song is random, and each has three levels of note shots. The PinTips community calls Tiny Dancer the easiest, since shooting its target adds more lit shots.
Each level lights a wardrobe item at the backstage shot, the inner loop. The first item starts 30 seconds of Double Song, the second gives Double Notes, and the third turns on Victory Laps: every shot scores 3M, rising by 100,000 a shot up to 5M, until the song ends. Collect all three in one song for a milestone.
The Rocka-Box
Hitting the drop targets fills the nine squares in front of them, and each full grid awards an album. The order is fixed. These are the first six, and in a short game they matter most.
| Album | Award |
|---|---|
| 1 | Rocka-Box points |
| 2 | Rocket fuel (1/5 of a tank) |
| 3 | Higher hurry-up value |
| 4 | 15 seconds of ball save |
| 5 | Opens the five encore modes |
| 6 | Rocka-Box Party frenzy |
The fourth one is the reason to shoot the drops early in a ball. An instant 15-second ball save is worth more than most jackpots in a three-ball game.
Multiballs, and how to stack them
Crocodile Rock. The Tiny Dancer target lights lock at the crocodile VUK on the right. The first Crocodile Rock needs two locks, later ones need three. Shoot the flashing shots for jackpots, then the crocodile for the super jackpot. A quick second lock at the crocodile, within 10 seconds, doubles the super jackpot.
Rocket Man. Fuel comes from all over the game, and the rocket shot adds 50 units. The first tank is 500 units. Once it is full the rocket kicker lights to start. You can wait and keep fueling for perks:
| Extra fuel | Perk |
|---|---|
| 100 | Extra ball saver |
| 200 | Easier super jackpot |
| 300 | One more ball, and a milestone |
| 400 | All jackpots stay lit |
Only these two can stack, and with both running, jackpots in both double. Few tournament games get better than that.
During any multiball, the hurry-up target near the left eject adds a ball once the ball save has run out, and again after a super jackpot.
Signature Stage, and the trap in it
Collect all nine ELTON JOHN stars to light lock at the side ramp, then lock three balls in the piano. The STAR inlanes and outlanes spot a letter when you complete them. You choose the tour with the action button. The rulesheet's rule of thumb: the older tours have longer ball saves and the newer ones pay more. 2023 London has no ball save at all.
The trap is that Signature Stage locks out the other multiballs while it runs. If Crocodile Rock or Rocket Man is close, play those first. In a tournament, the earlier tours are the safer pick.
Bonus and milestones
The end-of-ball bonus counts notes, albums and milestones, multiplied by a bonus X that rises when you complete the STAR lanes. The flippers move the lit lane, so a quick lane change before the ball reaches them is free bonus.
Four milestones light the Final Tour wizard mode. That is a long road in three balls. The cheapest milestone is the combo one, since a single three-shot combo counts by default.
Where the ball drains
The left outlane is the one the game gives you tools for. A Honky Cat hurry-up lights a kickback there: hit the target near the left eject, shoot the left eject, then make the lit shot from the left flipper before the hurry-up runs out. You can hold up to three kickbacks, and if one fails to return the ball you get a compensation ball save.
Ball save is the other tool. The fourth album and the Rocket Man fuel perks both add it, and the London tour takes it away. The sources we used say little else about drains, so watch the first player's ball.
What the tracked games say
| Tracked tournament games | 292 |
| Tournaments it appeared in | 176 |
| Players with a game on it | 209 |
| Typical game | 20:17 |
| Upset rate | 30.6% |
| Difficulty | 33 out of 100 |
Numbers are as of early November 2026. The Elton John machine page has the live ones.
The upset rate is how often the lower-rated player in a pairing finishes ahead. Elton John's 30.6% is five points under the 35.7% average across the 98 machines with 150 or more games. Long, layered games tend to reward whoever knows the rules. If you are the favorite in your group it is a sound pick. If you are the underdog, it is about 20 minutes of being the underdog. The full ranking is in upset rates by machine.
Play order hardly matters here: in 153 full four-player games, each seat won between 34 and 41 times (see does play order matter).
One record stands out. Among players with at least 20 games on it, Adam Turgeson has 19 outright wins in 26 games and has finished last once. Bryan Moen is next with seven outright wins in 21 games, then Trevor Klungseth with six in 20 and Rich Johnston with five in 20. No scores have been recorded on it yet, so run the scouting report against your group before you pick it.
Where to play it
- LITT Pinball Bar in Minneapolis, 136 tracked games since January 2024, on the floor as of early November 2026. See the LITT guide.
- Blainbrook in Blaine, 127 tracked games since January 2024, also on the floor. See the Blainbrook guide.
- Full Tilt Tavern has 29 tracked games on it since October 2025, the latest on November 5, 2026, though the venue's listed lineup does not show one. Check the venue page before you go. The Full Tilt guide covers the room.
Before your next game
The Elton John playbook collects tips, videos and rulesheet links, and the games tab lists the tournament games on record. The rules above come from the Pinball Rulesheets wiki page (written for code version 2.03, so later code may differ) and the player tips on PinTips.
Steve Ritchie also designed Firepower, Spider-Man, The Getaway and Game of Thrones. The whole series is in the machine strategy guides.